Mackenzie Shirilla

Self

Tim Troup

Assistant Prosecutor

Rosie Graham

Friend

Bubba Turner

Friend

Faythe Walsh

Childhood Friend

Steve Shirilla

Mackenzie's Father

Natalie Shirilla

Mackenzie's Mother

Frank Russo

Dominic's Father

Christy Russo

Dominic's Mother

Angelo Russo

Dominic's Brother

Christine Russo

Dominic's Sister

Davyne Flanagan

Davion's Sister

Scott Flanagan

Davion's Father

Jaime Flanagan

Davion's Mother

Dominic Russo

(archive footage)

Davion Flanagan

(archive footage)

Elliot Rawson

Ohio State Highway Patrol

Ryan Fox

Ohio State Highway Patrol

James McDonnell

Mackenzie Shirilla's Lawyer

Nancy M. Russo

Judge

Christopher Martin

Christy Russo's Friend